1

Very small amounts of MSG significantly enhance the flavour of coffee.

One may or may not like this enhancement (just as one may or may not like the addition of sugar), but that's not what I'm asking about.

Unlike with the addition of vanillin or other artificial flavours, many people seem to react very badly to the thought of anyone using MSG.

What are the serious reasons for this negative attitude?

(Note that any answer that repeats the myth that MSG is bad for one's health will be downvoted.)

7
  • Hmm are you asking specifically about coffee? Isn't this more of a cooking question as MSG is used as an addition in many dishes (so it has a broader audience there) while reasons for disapproving probably hold regardless of whether it's added to coffee or other dishes?
    – JJJ
    Commented Jul 18, 2022 at 13:55
  • @JJJ, I'm specifically asking about coffee. Commented Jul 18, 2022 at 14:23
  • 1
    I've never heard of anyone adding MSG to their own coffee, let alone it being widespread enough that anyone thinks to discourage the idea of doing it. Years ago, there were some articles claiming some big coffee packagers were adding it to the coffee or packaging to make their coffee more addicting, but I never saw any evidence that it was actually happening. Can you link to something for context about who is doing or promoting it, or warning not to do it?
    – fixer1234
    Commented Jul 19, 2022 at 19:07
  • 1
    You may be misinterpreting the "dog droppings" reaction; Kopi Luwak drinkers like cat droppings, so maybe it's more a matter of curiosity. :-) Articles like the ones you linked to were all wild speculation that was disproved in lab tests (coffee doesn't need additives like MSG to be addicting). The "No MSG" heading on the coffee sale page is like "Gluten Free" on products that never contained gluten--just marketing BS. People cringing when they hear you do it is probably just a matter of it sounding unusual. They would probably also cringe if you told them you put peanut butter on bologna.
    – fixer1234
    Commented Jul 19, 2022 at 19:58
  • 1
    @fixer1234, as a matter of fact, I do put peanut butter on liver (or sliced beef or chicken). But if I call it "satay" instead, people think it's delicious. Commented Jul 19, 2022 at 20:04

2 Answers 2

1

Over the years, there have been wild claims about various (or most) coffee packagers adding MSG to either their coffee or the packaging, supposedly to make their product more addicting or at least more popular. People react negatively to such claims for many obvious reasons -- they've heard that MSG is harmful, they don't want adulterated coffee, they don't want to be duped or manipulated, etc. There has never been any actual evidence that any coffee packager actually did this, and lab tests disproved the claims when specific coffee companies were targeted.

Some retailers now put "No MSG" notices on their coffee offerings for the same BS marketing reasons they put "gluten free" on products that never contained gluten. So to the extent people are aware of the disinformation campaigns or see the "No MSG" notices, they are likely to frown on it as someone adulterating their food.

I suspect the negative reaction to hearing that you do it is either the same generalized reaction (if it's bad for coffee packagers to do it, why would you do it yourself?), or the fact that it's an unusual substance to add to coffee. For example, some people are aware that adding a small amount of salt to coffee can enhance the taste (if you like that); the people who aren't aware of it often consider it strange when they hear about it. And adding MSG is far more unusual. Some people are adventurous, and anxious to try new things. Others cringe at the idea of things that sound unusual.

You may have jumped to a conclusion that there must, or could, be a good reason not to add MSG to coffee based on the often negative reaction people have to the idea. The negative attitude can be explained, but I'm not aware of factual or compelling supporting reasons not to do it (other than the person believing that small amounts of MSG are harmful).

1

I've been putting a pinch of MSG in my coffee grounds for years. It cuts any bitter back notes and enhances the flavor regardless of the quality of the beans that you are grinding ( I personally only use very high quality arabica). Tasted side by side, one with and one without, The one with is definitely brighter and has better flavor tones. I also use MSG while cooking. Personally I think MSG gets a bad rap. It is naturally occurring in many of the foods that we consume daily anyways. As to why people are complaining about it being used in coffee I have no idea. Those persons should probably just go away and let us live our lives.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.