I'm not sure how to explain this, but my question is that before I press it the grounds are already at the bottom of the pressor and the coffee seems "light". The taste is also quite sour (but I believe this is because I let it steeped longer that 4 minutes?)

Is it because the ground is too coarse? Attaching the image below:

This is the coffee ground's size

Thank you for the help!

  • 1
    Does it not float at al, or does it only sink to the bottom later in the brew?
    – JJJ
    Jun 25, 2021 at 8:30
  • You should take a look at this other question.
    – Elfarto
    Jun 25, 2021 at 17:43

2 Answers 2


It is perfectly normal for the grounds to fall to the bottom relatively soon, even before pressing. In fact, you don't even need to press, you can just use the plunger as a strainer when you're done brewing. If your coffee tastes too sour, it is most probably underextracted. A weak ("light") body also hints at underextraction. To increase extraction you can let it brew for a longer amount of time, use hotter water, stir it or (the only really sane and repeatable solution) grind the coffee finer. As with all recipes for coffee: try to keep it as repeatable and consistent as possible.


These things can affect grind buyoancy:

  • Roast level--lighter tends to be more buoyant due to greater retention of gasses during roasting

  • Roast freshness--fresher roasts retain more gasses due to less time spent off gassing; this effect is compounded by roast level

  • Grind freshness--fresher grinds retain more gasses due to less time spent off gassing

  • Grind level--coarser grinds retain more gasses due to less exposed surface area to facilitate off gassing; this effect is compounded by grind freshness

  • Brew water temperature--grinds retain gas longer at lower brew temperatures because colder water is a less effective solvent than hot water

  • Brew duration--the shorter the brew, the more gas is retained. Y the grinds; this effect is compounded by brew water temperature

So your problem is essentially impossible to diagnose without some experimentation. But there's a good chance the sour flavor is not related to the sinking grinds. Most likely, your sinking grinds are due to coffee that has lost most of it's natural gasses. Check the roast date on the bag. Anything older than about two weeks is probably well degassed with whole bean, and anything older than about four hours is likely well degassed with ground coffee. If you grind at home, grind right before you brew to minimize this possibility. But don't feel bad about sinking grinds. They won't affect your brew but might coincidentally be caused by factors that do affect your brew.

The sour taste, on the other hand, probably has to do with extraction as suspected, but the problem is on the other side of things. It's likely that your grind is too coarse and you're under extracting. Try dialing down the grind a bit, and keep your brew time to four minutes (which is the generally accepted ideal for French press).

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.